Il ritorno in Standard di carte Selvagge con la patch dell’8 ottobre ha sicuramente dato uno scossone al meta di Hearthstone, ma ha anche aumentato la potenza dello Sciamano a livelli preoccupanti per la community. La Magia No name available, in combinazione con No name available
e No name available
può produrre situazioni che anche Vicious Syndicate definisce “opprimenti”.
In una delle ultime discussioni su Twitter è intervenuto anche Dean “Iksar” Ayala, uno dei responsabili del bilanciamento, che ha stimolato la conversazione e l’ha proseguita anche su reddit. Il punto di partenza è stato il messaggio dello streamer Jesse Alexander, che ha ormai preso l’abitudine di taggare Iksar con foto di situazioni tipiche di chi gioca contro Sciamano.
Per i giocatori il nucleo del problema è la rapidità con cui è possibile generare servitori ad alto costo nelle prime fasi del gioco, dove solo Guerriero e Paladino hanno strumenti di risposta. Questo fa scaturire quindi un senso di impotenza e frustrazione se si gioca un’altra classe o nel mirror match.
A differenza del caso del Sacerdote Ayala non ha fatto intendere se vogliano intervenire o meno, ma ha reiterato alcuni concetti base del bilanciamento: nelle decisioni del team vengono presi in considerazione sia dati statistici che i feedback soggettivi dei giocatori, in particolare cosa piace, cosa non piace e le soluzioni preferite a certi problemi.
A detta di Iksar, nella maggior parte dei bilanciamento fatti in passato hanno “pesato” di più i feedback soggettivi.
TL;DR: J Alexander has a lot of passion for the game and a lot of experience to draw on, which is awesome. He also has no verbal filter and can come off as a bit of a jerk towards the devs, which is less awesome.Jalex has a lot of opinions and they are interesting to listen to, even if we disagree on many topics. We’ve known each other a while and I’d like to think our relationship allows for a little bit of snark.
The comment comes from a genuine interest on what he thinks the actual issues are and what he might change, not from a place of total ignorance on what sentiment among engaged audiences generally is. Many times someone will propose a solution or identify the piece of the thing that they don’t like that results in a discussion on our end. That’s mainly what I come here looking for. Also I just like Hearthstone so reading about it is fun.
Is there a particular type of feedback that you or your team members find especially constructive?
Yes. What you personally like or dislike, and what solutions to issues you would be happy with. Just like anything else, you can trust an individual to tell you how they feel but shouldn’t necessarily trust someone to tell you how someone else feels. Answering questions on behalf of others requires tons of research, analysis, data, experience, etc. As a designer, I know how difficult and borderline unanswerable some questions about large populations can be, so being asked to change or not change something from a single individual based on the thoughts and opinions of a large population is hard for me to trust. At least not without a lot of analysis to back up those opinions.
Anyway, the point is, we just want to hear what you think and what your experience is like. I feel like many players don’t like to give feedback this way because they don’t want it to come off as if they think the game should be made just for them. While that is true, the game isn’t made for any one particular person, having a ton of data points for how different people feel is ultimately how we make decisions.
Here’s the thing you guys (Team Five) have gotten wrong about the game from my perspective. Relying on quantitative is really good at identifying overperformance of decks and what’s making these decks really strong, but it doesn’t give you data into what’s really unfun. I don’t know how you would gather qualitative data effectively because of how large the player base is.
Data is just one point of reference, just like feedback. We don’t make decisions based on charts or individual feedback, they just all help contribute towards a final decision. Historically, we’ve made more balance changes based on around how something feels to play against rather than how powerful it is.

